Studio Ghibli vs. Disney Pixar

There is no doubt in my mind that Studio Ghibli has produced some of the best animation films the world has seen since its inception in 1985. However, despite all the achievements of creative geniuses including Miyazaki and Takahata, it would be wrong to say that they are the only ones producing such exceptional animation features. Pixar Animation Studios, a subsidiary of the Walt Disney Company, began its road to success in 1995 with the release of Toy Story. Since then, Pixar has won a multitude of awards; its films highly regarded amongst both critics and the public. But are Pixar films really better than Ghibli ones? Or is it the other way around? Read on to find out!
 

Image Source

Visual Style

Let’s start with one of the most obvious differences: the animation style of the two studios. Ghibli films are produced primarily using traditional animation techniques, whilst Pixar makes use of CGI (Computer Generated Imagery). So what does this mean for the look of the films? The difference goes beyond Ghibli films being 2D and Pixar’s 3D. Each and every frame in Ghibli films is drawn by hand, and the smallest details (such as a flower in the background) are never overlooked. Knowing this makes us appreciate their films even more, as each feature is a work of art. Pixar, focused on delivering high quality animations using the latest CGI technologies, lacks some of this attention to detail. Whilst both studios have very different visual styles, they are both of an exceptionally high standard.

Studio Ghibli
Image Source

Story

Both Studio Ghibli and Pixar films are highly unique and imaginative. However, Ghibli movies have more varied stories, many drawing ideas from folklore and mythology. The Japanese film studio also understands that often simple is best, with many of their films having no life-threatening scenarios leaving viewers on the edge of their seat. (There are exceptions of course.) Often the beauty of Ghibli films arises from their simplicity and artistic merits. Studio Ghibli also doesn’t do sequels. Cars 2, Monsters University, Finding Dory... It’s almost as though Pixar has run out of ideas!

Disney Pixar
Image Source

Emotion

Clearly if both studios can produce great stories, it must mean they stir the audience emotionally as well. Let’s face it, Studio Ghibli’s Grave of the Fireflies would make even the strongest of people shed a few tears. But even Ghibli cannot compare to the heartbreaking opening scenes of Pixar’s Up and the loneliness of Wall-E as he roams around on an abandoned Earth. And the clever visual jokes present throughout Pixar films are not to be forgotten either.

Wall-E
Image Source

And the winner is...

Both! Yeah I know, you’re probably thinking what a disappointing and indecisive conclusion this is. But, as you’ve probably noticed, this is a blog all about Studio Ghibli, and I’m not going to pretend our view on this isn't just a little bit biased. The truth is, it’s all up to your own individual tastes and there is no right or wrong answer. No matter which animation studio you prefer, both produce extraordinary films with visually stunning animation and stories that captivate all audiences.

But hey, who says you have to choose between the two? WHY NOT HAVE BOTH? If you take a look at the picture below, you’ll see Mei from My Neighbor Totoro. She looks a tad different though, doesn’t she? This is what she would probably look like if Studio Ghibli decided to adopt 3D CGI animation like Pixar. Have a look at the article, If Studio Ghibli Made Pixar Films, They’d Look Like This, it’s definitely worth checking out!

 

References:

• Wikipedia – Studio Ghibli and Pixar

• HubPages – Studio Ghibli vs. Pixar: A comparison

• Time Out – Studio Ghibli Vs Disney Pixar: an animated debate

• Yahoo Movies – What Disney Could Learn From Studio Ghibli

 Post by Chloe